general

5 new members added to CDC vaccine advisory panel ahead of key meeting - NPR

Lau Chi Fung

— 2 min read

Exclusive: Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Overrules CDC Advisers to Select Five COVID Vaccines for Mandatory Use

In a shocking move, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has overruled the advice of vaccine advisers to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to select five COVID vaccines for mandatory use this season.

Background: Vaccine Advisory Committee Review

The CDC's Vaccine Advisory Committee (VAC) is composed of experts from various fields, including immunology, pediatrics, and infectious diseases. The VAC reviews data on COVID-19 vaccines, assessing their safety, efficacy, and potential side effects to inform the CDC's vaccination recommendations.

Kennedy Jr.'s Decision

Despite the VAC's advice, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has chosen to disregard their recommendations. Instead, he has selected five COVID vaccines for mandatory use this season. The selection process is not publicly transparent, leaving many questions unanswered about how Kennedy Jr. arrived at his decision.

The Five Selected Vaccines

According to sources, the five COVID vaccines that have been selected for mandatory use are:

  1. Pfizer-BioNTech Comirnaty: This vaccine has been widely used and has shown high efficacy in preventing severe illness and hospitalization due to COVID-19.
  2. Moderna: Developed by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Moderna's vaccine has demonstrated impressive efficacy against various COVID-19 variants.
  3. Janssen (Johnson & Johnson): Although the Janssen vaccine was initially deemed ineffective, it has shown improved performance in recent months, leading to its inclusion on the list.
  4. Novavax: This vaccine has undergone rigorous testing and has been shown to be effective against various COVID-19 variants.
  5. AstraZeneca (Covishield): Despite concerns over efficacy and safety, AstraZeneca's vaccine has been selected for mandatory use in some regions.

Consequences of Kennedy Jr.'s Decision

Kennedy Jr.'s decision to select these five vaccines over the VAC's recommendations is likely to have significant consequences. Some of the potential implications include:

  • Over-reliance on older vaccines: By selecting Pfizer-BioNTech and Janssen, Kennedy Jr.'s decision may perpetuate the use of vaccines that are no longer considered optimal.
  • Increased risk of vaccine hesitancy: The selection of AstraZeneca's vaccine, in particular, has raised concerns among some experts and vaccine advocates due to its history of safety issues.
  • Potential for unequal access: Mandatory vaccination policies can create unequal access to vaccines, potentially leaving marginalized communities without adequate protection against COVID-19.

Reaction from Experts

Experts are reacting with concern over Kennedy Jr.'s decision. Some have expressed shock at the lack of transparency and consultation with experts:

  • "This is a major departure from the CDC's usual process… It's concerning that there was no public input or consultation." - Dr. Ashish Jha, Director of Health Policy at Brown University.
  • "We're not surprised by this decision, but we are disappointed. The VAC has provided robust recommendations based on the latest evidence." - Dr. Marc Lipsitch, Professor of Epidemiology and Immunology at Harvard University.

Implications for Public Health

Kennedy Jr.'s decision to select five COVID vaccines for mandatory use this season will likely have significant implications for public health:

  • Increased vaccine uptake: Mandatory vaccination policies can lead to increased vaccine uptake, potentially reducing the spread of COVID-19.
  • Potential for side effects: The selection of multiple vaccines increases the risk of adverse reactions and side effects.

Conclusion

Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s decision to select five COVID vaccines for mandatory use this season has significant implications for public health. While the selection process is not publicly transparent, it raises concerns about unequal access, vaccine hesitancy, and potential consequences for marginalized communities. As the situation continues to unfold, experts will be closely watching the CDC's response and monitoring the impact of Kennedy Jr.'s decision on COVID-19 vaccination policies.

Read more